I was just in the middle of the same debate. I usually do this, and end up with the IC. I'd say it also depends how many points you have. The IC is only 5,000 more points than the CP, which to me seems worth it. It's 10,000 more than Chateau Le Moyne and Indigo, which are also popular options. That 70,000 point different between the week is up to you. If you have the IHG Premier card, you can book them 8 nights for the price of 6 at any of these properties.