I've been in LH PEY often enough that I would pick it over Y any day. However never been in a SH PEY.
About to book a PEY return ticket SYD-TOKYO, on the return leg, 17th June, the only available flight for me with PEY is CX509 ex NRT at 9:15 (unable to take 4pm one as being too late), would you guys choose it over sitting in Y CX543 ex HND at 10:35? Is it really only the seat difference, not the service (food and pre flight drink)?
It will be the same price and same status credit (E vs H). HND obviously closer and brings me extra 2 hours of sleep in my bed.