Originally Posted by
cyborg
I did mention that she should at least try some Luca Malbec (available locally) since Laura Catena is/was a UCSF doctor who happens to be part of the Catena wine family and that she should try at least a bottle of that before judging the whole county on whatever basis she had previously...
Tasting Luca as your "introduction to Malbec" will only lead to a lot of future disappointment, because at its price point (at least what Costco sells it for when it is available there), you aren't going to do any better. In fact, you can do worse for double that.
I'm rarely in any sort of corporate tasting room with multi-national conglomerate ownership. Not that it doesn't occasionally happen, but your Provenance experience is not atypical for such a visit. Still, I do wonder how someone dreams up the taste of "dirty" soil.