Oz, it's not quite as simple as that. There are too many grey areas.

How about my own signature: "Sir Dovster, OBE"? It is not religion or politics. On the other hand, it is not a plug for a do or an airline. On the third hand (which, obviously, I would have to borrow), it definitely does relate to Flyer Talk. Is it acceptable or not?

Or how about a signature which says, "Dismantle the TSA!" It refers to a governmental organization, so it could be considered politics. Yet the TSA impacts on all frequent flyers. Would this be allowed?

My initial reaction would be to rely on the good sense of the Flyer Talk posters. Unfortunately, experience -- even on the ORP thread -- has shown that good sense doesn't always play a part.

My next reaction would be to leave it up to the moderators. Again, however, there are too many examples of extremely provocative posts which the moderators have allowed to stand.

I like having signatures. I also liked having the reputation feature. I completely agree with everyone who states that the features themselves are not the problem -- their abuse is.

It is only when we Flyer Talkers refuse to accept any kind of extremism or purposely provocative behavior -- even from people on our own side of the political fence -- that this kind of behavior will cease.