I have no real list...I wanted to say I enjoy this thread (especially when folks explain why they rank as they do) as it gives me a little more insight of which ones to put on my list...I personally have only been to two:

Amanbagh: great hard product and service...but the location for me was not that trilling (rural...I've seen this many times in Asia) as other places that we visited on the same trip (eg Lake Palace, oberoi both in Udairpur).
Amanyara: good hard product, underwhelmed service, food and beach. Not go back.