Originally Posted by
Often1
3. Delay - Given that the cancellation has already caused a delay at SFO of more than four hours, unless there is an "extraordinary circumstance" OP is entitled to EUR 600.
The reference to "delay" and "four hours" is confusing (and superfluous). [Again, not to labour the point, but the concept of "delay" plays no part here; case law has led to the interpretation of long delays being handled as a cancellation, but in this case, we are clearly dealing with a simple cancellation. I also don't know where you came up with "four hours" - it seems that you are thinking of the case of when a "long delay" is handled under the regulation as a "cancellation". In the present case, the flight was cancelled, and the offered replacement flight wasn't until several days afterwards - not that calculating the time to that replacement flight matters in any way, given that we are dealing here with a simple and uncontested cancellation]
A cancellation at such short notice automatically requires compensation, except where actual "extraordinary circumstances" can be proven. This applies to all customers on the affected flight - regardless of whether they opt for re-imbursement; regardless of whether they are re-routed without any delay; regardless of whether they are re-routed with delay [which can lead to additional compensation under other Articles]; regardless of whether they are re-booked on another day.
All passengers on a flight that is cancelled at such short notice and which was cancelled for reasons that cannot be justified as "extraordinary circumstances" are due compensation (€600 for this particular flight).