I should have noted this before, but the water shoes were never mentioned or offered to us by the resort. If I had not read reviews beforehand, I would have had no idea they were available. When we were there in early March, there were two huge baskets of shoes right next to the paddle boards and kayaks on the beach. It's easy to miss, and I didn't see anyone else take them the whole time we were there. Hopefully the shoes are there and hiding, rather than not being offered at all!