I agree with you. I think if Hyatt was smart they'd comp you Diamond. Especially if you explained what happened and that the reason you stopped staying at Hyatt 4 years ago was only because you went to a new city that didn't have a Hyatt. Hyatt should at least take the time to research back and see that in fact you did stay ~200 nights 4 year ago after requesting a status match. I think Hyatt did pretty well off your last status match and they would be smart to give you another status match if you said you intend to stay with them again. You may want to contact Julia, she's EXTREMELY helpful and might be able to help you out.