In that case I'd take the Club supplement discount, but maybe counter propose 150$. We used the Club every day for breakfast, high tea and evenings drinks and even ordered our dinner there from room service menu every evening (they serve it after drinks are done at 7:30pm). Overall worth it in my book just for the calmer and more civilized environment. The Club team is very helpful and trying hard. While not everything maybe super perfect they take feedback to heart and act and are genuinely looking to please. Can't complain. YMMV.