Flamboyant... one idea to find a relatively inexpensive place is to do a search of this forum under "New YOrk" for all the places Flyertalkers have gone to.
Also check out the NYC dining threads on Travel and DIning Buzz. Lots of write ups on lots of good restaurants there.
You may also find a place under your own, but you can find places LESS than 60 a person in NYC.
Unfortunately I work late Fridays so I won't be able to join you all.