Originally Posted by
maniac78
Just thought I'd bump this thread to annoy everyone here.
I just came back from a mixed itinerary in first class on AS and AA and while both were good AS wins hands down. The seats were way better in AS for sure and the service was fantastic. I did like that on one flight out of the 4 on AA I got a PDB which AS doesn't offer but I mean AA advertises that as part of their service and pretty much never delivers so that's that. Also it was nice to use the AS lounge whereas of course you need status or certain routes to use the AA ones.
Wow. I did CLL-DFW-PDX in F on AA last month and AA was hands down better (this was a 738 on the DFW-PDX section). More comfortable seat, better seat amenities (e.g. places to actually put things at your seat besides the seat back pocket), more plentiful food. Service interaction was comparable to AS.