We also are looking into one of those properties for a stay in the coming years. Our research has us leaning towards Clayoquot due to its apparently incredibly high service and food/beverage standards, as well as the diversity of experiences and excursions. It also seems a bit more adventurous while still being luxury, IMO, with the tents and location (and climate). But the cabins at the other lodges seem very comfortable...and it seems you could combine them into one trip more easily if desired.

Might I add, hopefully without any hint of condescension, how impressed I am that you both seek out such adventurous destinations that typically require more vigor and conditioning than you concede you ordinarily exhibit. I think that’s absolutely fabulous...and quite rare IME. Your interests and preferences and ours frequently seem to overlap despite our very different physical capabilities (and ages).

I can’t speak for anyone else, but I adore you for that and hope our paths will cross at some point at one of these properties!