Originally Posted by BESVISOR

In my experience, (myself, with clients and speaking with resort management) many of those who are returning guests that have already done the "Over Water" experience actually much prefer the beach accommodation. Once the novelty is worn off.
Many cases, it offers more space. I believe when I visited the Beach Accommodations at St. Regis, it was a duplex, thus, more space and direct beach access. Closer to the pool, whale bar and Aba restaurant as well, or at least it felt like it.

Cheval Blanc often sells their beach villas more than the overwater option as well.

We also visited One & Only prior to St. Regis Maldives and it was a no brainer for us to stay in the beach villa over the over water option there, based on our personal taste.

But I hope you'll enjoy it, no matter which you end up in!