Originally Posted by
Transpacificflyer
Ok. Let's bring this back to the issue at hand...
Great idea. As
cow points out, that issue is the legitimacy of emotional support animals; not service animals.
First, I’m curious to know where you stand with respect to the concept of ESAs in general? It’s clear from the commentary here that many FTers dismiss the whole concept as bogus pseudo-science.
Second, assuming you do believe there is a legitimate medical case for ESAs in some cases, do you agree with the (again apparent FT) consensus that the concept is subject to abuse?
My personal views on this are captured well by
this NYT article. Some choice quotes below:
But their presence on airplanes is increasingly facing a backlash from flight attendants, passengers with allergies and owners of service animals, like Seeing Eye dogs, who say that airplane cabins have become crowded with uncaged animals who have no business being there.
“It’s becoming a big problem,” said Marcie Davis, founder of International Assistance Dog Week. “I’ve seen people bring on pets and try to pass them off as an emotional support or service dog. It’s not appropriate and it’s not safe.” [...]
“Assistance dogs are trained not to bark in public, not to go smelling other dogs or people,” she said. “I’ve had my dog attacked in multiple situations. Honestly, I understand that there’s some value that people need an emotional assistance dog. But I think a lot of this is that people love their dogs and think they feel like if you have your dog, why can’t I have mine?”
To serve the needs of the animals and their owners, a cottage industry of websites and doctors advertising documents that certify emotional support animals has emerged.
Carla Black, a psychotherapist in Marina del Rey, Calif., began receiving enough requests for emotional support animal certification that this year she began advertising on her website. For $99, she provides an hour of her time, over the phone or Skype, and a clinical assessment, along with a prescription letter, which is valid for one year.