It’s precisely why I’ve almost left Accor and have already 19 stays next year with SPG. Even as an Accor Plat you only get a one-category upgrade, which as you said, can just mean a higher floor or better view. This is basically an enhanced room similar to SPG Gold. For Plats it is the « best available room including standard suites » and guaranteed 4 pm check out! No more begging bowls! If Accor changes I may consider returning but i won’t hold my breath!