If you're booking the first week of Nov., you might want keep checking fares. You could possibly get an AA YUP fare for a lot less than the fares you're pulling up now.

If CO wouldn't be the most economical way, I'd choose any of the other four except Delta. If you do a search you'll find a lot of valuable information regarding the best F product to HNL. In fact, you'll find it in every one of the airline forums you listed above.

Good luck!

aloha