My wife and I stayed over Mem W/E. Since we are not used to frequenting hotels (above and beyond the Dolphin and Swan), we were relatively more satisfied. Standard Plus Member. They offered me Club Level for an additional 30.00 per night getting us into the lounge and fitness center. Yay! They never charged me the 90.00 for the upgrade, so it was all gravy to me. Room 1412. Nice room overall, except that we learned (via the knock on the door at 4:30am by security) that our door did not automatically close! Yikes! Pathetic Naive Floridians! Twice daily maid service, good shower pressure, UGLY view, great bed. Shula's awesome, spa treatments good. Seemed worth the 30K Starpoints spent. I was surprised to find that my spa treatments were NOT eligible for points. I was bummed as I was hoping for 600 points for 300 bucks of facial crap and rub downs. I was told by SPG tonite that in NY, spa and room service are not eligible. Is this true, folks? Anyway, thanks to all who helped with my Westin vs. W debate and assistance to/from LGA. GO SOX!