I'ld go back to Amangiri. I don't think we had quite the issue with service fails; though the level wasn't as high as I would like. Food was definitely not to the level that I desired too.. However, it is truly a stunning stunning locale. Loved the pool. Great area to wander and hike around. Spa was solid. We definitely relaxed during our visit.
And I've heard they've replaced the Keurig with Nespresso so things are definitely looking up...
FDW