I'll admit, I have limited experience with Element, other than Boston. I really like the Element there (though I more frequently stay at the Westin down the block) -- it's in the seaport area, and its very modern.

I get it, it's Boston -- it's not inexpensive. But when I look at the amenities, the cost, etc. it just doesn't compute for me that all of the SPG perks are halved ala Four Points. I've never paid less than $225 at the Element, and I often pay over $300/night, so it seems REALLY PETTY to halve the Platinum Arrival Gift points, the Green Choice points, etc.

I realize that it's a tiny amount of points, so it's not the points. Rather it seems really odd that the system seems to make (at least this) Element hotel into a second class brand, when there are many people who like the concept of a green hotel, etc.

Element might be structured more like a budget hotel in other brands (free breakfast, go green, etc.) but it's more like an extended stay Westin (even moreso in my opinion than an Aloft is a baby-W).

Don't get me wrong, I'd certainly like to see Aloft also treated on par, but I'll let someone else voice their opinion on that as I've only stayed at a couple of them...