Originally Posted by
Stgermainparis
I've never flown CX but may get some award tickets with 3 in J for our kids (ages will be 18, 15, 9) and 2 in F for us (mostly b/c many of the flights I'm looking at don't have 5x in J). We will be on several segments with CX in and out of HKG. I'm wondering if our kids can go into the Pier lounge with us (policy looks like each F pax gets one guest, but we've got one extra). It's fine if we can only use the J lounge, but I wanted to ask.
Maybe yes, maybe no. Definitely don't expect it. Being honest....the Pier J is waaayyyyy better for a family. I'm CX DM (Cathay's OWE equivalent), but I go to Pier J about half the time I'm in the Pier area, instead of F. Once you have 4-5 passengers, it becomes even more no-brainer to go to Pier J. Huge, tons of different rooms / unique food areas, and just massive quantities of seating and a lot of different vibes. The F lounge really sucks for families IMO, except to say you're cool and eating in a free mediocre a la carte restaurant or this is the F lounge. Back to my praising of the Pier J lounge, there are day beds in the back, a tea salon, a whole a la carte buffet area, a noodle room, espresso cart, it's good. Pier F self-serve food options just completely suck. It's this tiny "pantry" concept that looks aesthetically pleasing and is quite useless based on what they normally stock in there. J self-serve food absolutely blows F away not even close. So the problem with F is, unless you're sitting down at that (mediocre) restaurant, you really don't have good food options at all. And no I don't always want to eat at a damn restaurant, especially one that frequently mixes up my order, can't always be relied upon for speed, and honestly doesn't have that great of food compared to what I can eat in town an hour before.
I really don't think I'm going out on a limb and saying Pier J is hands down the best option for a family of 5. I often choose it as my own option as a party of ONE, and its utility only goes up with a group.
I think Pier J is arguably the best lounge in HKG, including over the F lounges.
Oh, and if you're into wine, it's not like Pier F offers anything much better. If you're serious about wine CX has atrocious offerings in both lounges. But the hard products are stunning - I'd go so far to say that Pier J is possibly the best J lounge in the world, at least in the very top echelon. Absolutely better than scores of F lounges.
Originally Posted by
Stgermainparis
Also, assuming they are well-behaved (they are), is there any problem with parents being in different section and/or with trading seats for one of our flights? My guess is that on some of the shorter routes, we will split up and do something like Dad + one teen and then Mom + other teen.
Switching mid-flight is not allowed. You are allowed to swap the passengers at boarding (against what name is on the seat), but you can't let someone have F half the flight, and someone else have it the other half.
If you're just talking about different flights...aka mom/dad take it this flight, kids take it next flight (regardless of whose names on BP), that's not a problem.
Originally Posted by
Stgermainparis
From photos, it looks like the F seats are wide enough for another person to join for a bit (or sit across from?). Is it possible for one of our teens to come sit with me in F for a while? I don't want to break the rules, but I'm curious why the wider seat.
Also not allowed. The people sitting in F can use it, but people from J and Y are not permitted in.
There are many threads about it. I've seen this a lot, and it's denied almost every time. I have seen a few exceptions but they're very rare.
The most normal "exception" is if a kid is in the back, and two parents are in front and there's an empty F seat. They'll usually let the kid sit in F for landing so they can be together to deplane and catch their connection. That's about the only normal exception I see.
Seen more rejections than I can count. Otherwise, you'd have people buying 1 F seat and just hosting parties. That's not the spirit of it.