Definitely exceeds StR Bora Bora - it's not even a competition as they aren't in the same league.

The hard product is beyond AMAZING. Everything is gorgeous, high end, and impeccably designed, both in general and with the guest in mind. Even the facilities (water treatment, air conditioning, trash / recycling, etc.) are cool enough that they give tours.

We did the all-inclusive plan and it was such a treat to have spa appointments included in our rate. It also was refreshing to not have to consider pricing for F&B, especially after the sky high amounts we paid in Bora Bora. My Champagne intake went up 1000%

I highly recommend The Brando for anyone looking for exclusivity, privacy, and relaxation. It often felt like we were the only people there. Aside from that our villa offered great privacy from the neighbors, and the view made it feel like you had your own private beach.

I felt there was room for improvement in terms of service, but I have extremely high standards and am a service above all else traveler. They also had not been open long when we were there, considering the low number of guests and the challenges of finding employees in FP in general.

I was also personally challenged by the food. If five course tasting menus and the associated cuisine are your thing, and you have no dietary restrictions, then dining here should be a great fit for you. I tend to prefer simple meals that are impeccably prepared. Plus, as a vegetarian, there were simply too few options in general, and that were appealing to me specifically.

The cocktail and wine programs were top notch and Bob's Bar was a highlight.

I don't have any reason to go back. I experienced the resorts that I felt would most appeal to my clients, which was one purpose of the trip. It's very far from Boston, and with a responsibility to my career to see the world it simply wouldn't make sense to return.

Here are my trip reports: The Brando, St. Regis vs. Four Seasons, Luxury Resort Showdown in French Polynesia