This thread has sold me on trying JWBlue the next time I see it at a reasonable price.
I prefer a high end rum when I am buying bottles for an after work nip. When I am out though, I have been arm twisted by colleagues to try out some whiskey/scotch items.
I realized I haven't found a single malt that really makes me go "wow".
I tried Hibiki 17 year old Japanese blended recently, on ice. It was smooth and tasted great. That shot though cost me probably $40.
I have tried the Highland Park stuff...I like the 18+ year stuff.
Those saying there isn't a big difference between 12 year and 18...it depends, but I can notice it in the smoothness. Also a big difference between 18 and 22 year for smoothness and flavor.
I recently tried 18 year Glenlivet and it wasn't for me.