Beach Resort for sure. That new water slide and kids play area looks epic. Also, huge kid's play room with video games, foosball, pool table and shuffle board. I will say the RI, at least from the outside, looks incredible but you want the beach. Go for the beach. Buy some peanut butter and jelly and make some sandwiches for lunch. Plus, they have high quality Boars Head meat at just about every convenience store in the area. We had a fridge in our room last week at the Beach Resort. Buy some milk and cereal too. I think once you see the kids pool area you'll know the answer. Seriously. Your kids are perfect ages for that kids pool area I think.