Hello FlyerTalk! Longtime lurker, first time poster. I find these threads very helpful so I figured I'd share my experience.
I picked up at HNL November 14th around 3:30 PM. If you arrive during their business hours you go directly to the 4th floor where there is a small counter for Emerald Club members. They have all the keys with them at the booth. The rep explained this is because there's no exit booth, so they need to check IDs and credit cards there. Selections were:
Executive:
2 Town & Countries
1 Sienna
EA:
.... a Sentra
There were a handful of other customers there, and without prompting the Rep apologized for the lack of the selection. She mentioned Sundays and Mondays are their busiest days, and that cars were being brought up as they returned. You can tell this location is very popular with the business crowd, as I drove down through Hertz, Avis, etc they seemed pretty well stocked.
I didn't want a van as I'm here on my honeymoon, so I waited a minute or two for a car to come. I ended up taking a 2016 Challenger with about 5,000 miles that had just come from the wash. Honestly I should have waited for something else because my back was killing me so I went back the next day to swap it out.
Tuesday November 15th, around noon:
Executive:
2x Honda CR-V LX
1x Subaru Forester Base
2x Malibu LT
2x Impala LT
1x Challenger
and I believe a Sienna
EA:
Literally every color Altima available. All 2017, all brand-spanking new. There were 3 3.5 SLs, 2 2.5 SLs, and the rest were SVs. Not bad for equipment choices!
I took one of the 3.5 SLs, which is fantastic! Leather, Sunroof, Factory Nav, Remote Start, etc etc etc. The same rep as the previous day helped me again. When she saw me get off the elevator, she chuckled "Hated the Challenger in Waikiki?" She mentioned they got two truck loads of Altimas yesterday a little before I arrived, but they needed to be plated and inspected. She also offered to call down to returns to see what else they had if an Altima wasn't up my alley, but the 3.5 SL is a great choice. Very friendly staff at this location and they seem to want to go out of their way to make sure you get what you want.
As a final note, the Premier cars were the same ones qs933 reported on Sunday. Looks like nobody has taken them up on their upgrades.