I have been on the hunt for the "perfect" bag for the past several years. I buy them, use them for a month and move on to the next one that includes all the positives of the prior bag and addresses the negatives.

As a result I have a lot of different bags that have either light or even no use (more than once I've gotten a bag that once it arrived and I see it in person I know just won't work for me).

So, lots of Red Oxx, Timbuktu, Minaal, etc luggage that I would sell not because they're bad but because they're not right for me. I'd say that the "why" is the critical piece of info. I'd be less worried about how someone used a high end bag - is someone who dropped $300 on an overnight bag really going to carry dead fish in it?