Today I tried to pay $3997 on a visa bill with a bank issued debit card (ST). CSR was willing to try. I've only ever tried to pay $2500 with checkfreepay and that was successful. And for the record, I and my card/account are in their system. Screen prompted CSR to ask for ID, which I provided (DL), and she entered info. Next screen apparently asked for second ID like a SS card. According to CSR it was actually asking for the ID and not just a # (in the past when I've paid mortgage of $2990 I've been prompted to enter a SS at the keypad). I don't carry SS card with me nor would I feel comfortable handing it over to CSR, so she canceled transaction and we did 2x $2k without any ID etc.

Has anyone done >$2500 without needing this second ID?