I suggest eating at the Greek Bistro, located in Kihei.
My wife and I have dined there the last three times that we have been to Maui and we enjoy the restaurant very much.
Food fare includes Greek dishes as well a Pacific choices as well. We were always satisfied with the food and service.
Prices for 2 can range from $50 to $90 depending upon what you select and whether you have wine.
This might be a nice place to celebrate a birthday.
I did some digging on the Internet and I find a link at:
http://www.dallasdinesout.com/restra...is/zizikis.htm
Seems that the owner of the Greek Bistro has also opened a couple of restaurants in Dallas Texas under the name Zizikis. You might want to check the site out for more info and an address in Kihei.
Have a nice trip to Maui.
Barry