Losing the AA membership could be a deal breaker for some but it will be close. If the airline reimbursement turns out to be incidentals only in the future that would be a big hit also. I didnt realize until reading another thread there are a lot of benefits tied to the World Elite status on this card so that could play into my decision to keep long term. Havent tested it but if you are able to stack the World Elite with the 4th night free then that might be enough for me along with PP lounge access and the $250 airline fee credit being for tickets also.