Greetings.

I have been trying to run my recent flying activity through a spreadsheet to see if changing over to QR from AA (I am Exec Plat / OWE).

When it comes to mileage credits for other OW flights the QCalculator sometimes awards bonus miles after reaching QR tiers 25% silver, 75% gold and 100% platinum. I've seen it on AA flights. Other times, specifically CX flights, these bonuses do not appear.

The documentation on tier levels suggest that there should not be tier mileage bonus on other OW marketed / operated flights.

So is the calculator wrong? or is are tier bonus miles awarded for AA flights after reaching silver, gold platinum in Privilege Club?