Since I originally posted in this thread I am glad to say I have had an amazing donut experience. Back Door Donuts on Martha's Vineyard (Oak Bluffs to be specific) is the best donut experience I have ever had. During the evenings Martha's Vineyard Gourmet Café & Bakery sells donuts, hot out of the over right from the back of their store. Their apple fritter is what they are known for, and it was amazing, but I tried a bunch of others and all were great. My pancreas probably hates me but what they serve is above and beyond. It is such an incredible experience that I would go to the island just to grab a donut.