Originally Posted by
beltway
That doesn't follow at all. You get a cert every year on your anniversary, so cert expiration doesn't say anything about the date of your signup bonus absent more info.
Sorry, not buying it. You may well have gotten multiple bonuses in the past (as I have), but it's not plausible that you've earned more than one signup bonus on any Chase card -- Marriott, IHG, or any other -- since July 2014.
Also, you're mistaken about approval implying bonus eligibility. Chase is notorious for approving applications even if the applicant is bonus-ineligible. (See the wiki at
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/chase...5-present.html, under "Great! So if I received the same card more than 2 years ago, I can apply again and get the bonus, right?")
Like I said, I was approved the 1st card on 7/27/13. I got my free night on 7/31/14. I don't know when I applied the 2nd card. I got approved the 3rd card on 3/24/2016 and 80K bonus on 4/27/16.
I have nothing to gain from this.