Trying to decide on here or The Laguna Nusa Dua for the SE Asia leg of our honeymoon. Anyone have a preference between the two?

I'm leaning towards the Andaman only because I've been to Bali already. We're mostly looking to relax for 5/6 nights. However, I'm a little concerned about the bad food reviews I've read, and that there's no off site options near by. How much does a taxi to "town" run?