No. Flyertalk is not dedicated to reviews of specific flights with the details of them. More specifcally, Information Desk is not the place to discuss them. As is noted in the START HERE sticky: "If your question involves…One specific airline or its mileage program - go to the Airlines and Mileage Programs index." If the OP has specific questions about SAS, he should review the SAS forum. http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/sas-eurobonus-499/. The closest place to "reviews" is Trip Reports: http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/trip-reports-177/

The OP references "one other review site and SAS gets an even share of bad and good reviews... ". Those "other review sites" are quite different - see, e.g., http://www.edreams.com/offers/flight...itish-airways/ , , http://www.airlinequality.com/airlin...unei-airlines/

If you want to be contrary as usual, go ahead, but there is no way you can with a straight face say that Flyertalk is designed to be like those "other review sites", though it has become an all-purpose place for anyone with any question about anything remotely travel related to come to instead of google.

If he wants to review detailed impressions of flights, he can scan the trip report forum. But these are not the same as "flight reviews".