Can you elaborate on why you prefer the Andaz over the FS and RC (now Montage)? Did you stay at those on the same trip or on previous trips? If previous, how long ago? Thanks!

I am booked for Thanksgiving 2016 at the Andaz for the Maui Invitational Basketball Tournament. The Montage Kapalua is closer to Lahaina, and we loved the Kapalua area and bay/beach on a stay at a property there that no longer exists. But can't book the Montage this far out. We are fans of FS, but have had mixed experiences in Hawaii at Hualalai and Manele Bay. Any details you can provide as to what you liked better about the Andaz will be greatly appreciated!