Originally Posted by
vuittonsofstyle
A newer option is Belmont Farm on Nevis -
http://www.bellemontfarm.com/ - designed by Bill Bensley - a completely different and authentic take on the Caribbean.
Otherwise, Malliouhana on Anguilla is an easy hop from Antigua and is a very good option.
On Antigua itself, Jumby Bay would be my choice - managed by Rosewood.
I may be confused-but I thought Belmont is on St. Kitts?
But more importantly--what is important to you for your holiday? Fine dining--Aguilla is supposed to be superb plus they have the whitest beaches with turquoise waters!
Ease of driving-I can only say Nevis was easy because it is small and no traffic lights. Did not drive on any other islands.
I stayed Peter Island and loved it but you are isolated.
Your budget is fine--perhaps narrow down what is important to you. Shopping, dining, tennis, golf, water sports, historical sights, etc.