Originally Posted by
jeet
Except I have seen this happen.
Colleague and I, both are diamond and in booked in the the same fare class. He booked before me but I have the reserve.
At the gate my name was above his in the upgrade list.
Cheers,
J
In a post several months ago I mentioned that I had done the same thing on two separate occasions, specifically as a test, with a co-worker and I had exactly the opposite experience from you.
Co-worker had Reserve card and booked exact same ticket for exact same fare one minute after me. On first occasion, I was upgraded at 5-day window, but he wasn't. On the next occasion, we were both upgraded at gate, but I was in front of him on upgrade list.