What a state American airlines are in - arguing about whether or not cookies are an appropriate course of service in first class, irrespective of time of day!!! Pathetic. Go ANYWHERE on this planet in F class on any carrier for anything more than about 45 minutes at ANY time of day, and passengers get a COOKIE??? OMG. Truly Stockholm Syndrome as evidenced by the comments of some of the responders. And the airline industry (including AS) is raking in revenue hand-over-fist - no thanks.