Originally Posted by
dayone
If by "many of us," you mean people who haven't flown in a premium cabin on AA's 77W and are comparing something they don't know, well then, OK.
I've flown on the 77W in both J and F multiple times. J is arguably as good as any carrier and F is certainly competitive.
Never been in either QF J/F or AA 77W J/F, but from the looks AA J is much better in terms of the seat. Not sure about the food, but I care more about seat comfort. Every seat having aisle access is very nice.