Originally Posted by
dank0014
IIRC, it is the check in number based upon the flight number. Meaning your flight may have a similar flight number that is operating earlier in the day. Could be wrong though
This is correct. Specifically, flight number and date as a pair.
As UA frequently use the same number for 2 or even 3 or more flights per day, you could be the first to check-in for your specific flight, and still be closer to 500 than 1.