Phuket.

Never been there, but for a honeymoon it's a more exotic vacation. From what people are saying you don't get breakfast there anymore but aren't there some hotels that have lounges in that area?

We enjoyed our vacation in Scrub Island 2 years ago and were upgraded to the one bedroom. I've read that now they want money to upgrade. It was a nice quiet resort on its own island. The BVI are beautiful. The pool at the resort was small and nothing special. Room was great.

You can do the Caribbean any time, Phuket is more special in my opinion and since there is not much difference in airfare, I say go for it. My kids went around that part of the world for their honeymoon and loved it.