I was able to get through this. At the end, it asked me if I wanted to update my employer, as I have regular emerald access via them. My expiration date used to show 2050 or something insane like that, but now it shows Feb of 2017.

It looks like this can still work, but for now I think I'll just leave mine alone. I've had good luck so far getting a ride I am OK with using my current status.