As a long standing Loyalty Member of many programs, espt *A, , I think their Best Before Date has expired on most programs. The rules have become so strict, the benefits so less and the rewards so few that it is time to announce the funeral on most Loyalty Programs.
One needs to spend too much time to figure out all of these new rules. Clearly the system does not want us.
I know AA's shines above others at this moment but it too will likely adjust itself into the new mold.
It was a great game when it lasted but it is pretty much over now. The benefits of flying 100,000 miles are pretty negligible, perhaps only 2 upgrades now, or 3, which is really not much for such loyalty and far less than in previous years.
I am thinking it is better to buy discounted J or P or Z fares rather than play the game anymore. Which is of course exactly what the Airlines want us to do.
I should point out that I have been very successful with up/gs over my career of 20 + yrs. Only once did I not get an up/g on a major *A carrier but I know that is not likely into the future.
100,000miler