True.

But if AY bothered with two lounges side-by-side I think they should have kept one as J lounge and one as F lounge. The current situation is that the Premium Lounge is often more crowded (thuogh, it is smaller) and the offerings could also be upgraded (if serving fewer people).

If the whole point is to benefit AY's own frequent flyers, which is totally fine, then they can offer access to Golds and Platinums from their own program and also Emeralds (only) from other programs in the alliance. It wouldn't be the first lounge to have such a policy.

Anyway... fantastic lounge in my book.