AA service in F has become horribly inconsistent of late. Coats are not taken until practically shoved in the faces of the FAs. No PDB on more than half of my flights (though I will say Eagle FAs do this well). Coats often not returned before landing. First Class gate check tags on the RJs are worthless as those bags never reach the jet bridge first. This said I do appreciate the ability to select my meal before departure and the power ports at all seats.

US ain't flashy but it is predictable and generally consistent. I do like the fact that when you order a cocktail on US the FA brings you a glass half-full of mixer and two, count 'em two, minis for you to mix it yourself. Makes it easier on them and on me.