FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Germanwings / 4U 9525 A320 Alpine plane crash 24 Mar 2015
Old Mar 29, 2015 | 6:11 pm
  #964  
Guava
FlyerTalk Evangelist
10 Countries Visited20 Countries Visited30 Countries Visited20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Nov 2000
Posts: 16,092
Originally Posted by JohnnyColombia
I think regardless of who can see what, Brice Robin's assertion that nobody knew until the last minute that something was wrong was particularly ambitious from the outset.

Most people are sophisticated enough to know that two hour flights do not reach cruising altitude and then start their descents immediately afterwards. I don't think you have to be an experienced flyer to recognise when a plane is losing altitude. You'd have to be buried in a really gripping novel to miss it.
Unfortunately, I think you are likely correct. When a plane starts to descend, you can sense it, maybe not for first time flyers but anyone who has flown a few times can pick it up. Based on the transcript provided, it looks as though the Captain rushed to come back to the cockpit. He left around 10:28-29, presumably was back 2 minutes later. Prosecutor Robin said that at first the Captain knocked lightly and asked to be allowed back in, then when hearing no answer, he started to bang more forcefully. The transcript made no mention of the part where the Captain started out by knocking softly on the door but did say by 10:32, he was already banging on the door and shouting. Assuming he was back at the door by 10:31, it's safe to say he sensed the descend while in the bathroom and immediately rushed back.

As for the sight of the mountains, a few years ago, while on a transcontinental flight, the Captain told us that the weather was really good so he would be flying lower than usual in order to give us some close up views of the Rockies. It was breathtaking. Of course, the Captain announced it beforehand but I am sure there were some pax who didn't understand English but it didn't look like anyone freak out. It is not rare that some Captains will purposely point out interesting natural wonders or sightseeing opportunities and intentionally adjust the flight to take advantage of the views. In most cases, they would say something, sometimes they don't but it's obvious they are adjusting the flight to let you see it. Just because we seem to be descending towards the Alps will not immediately raise a red flag to me because I know planes will also do that if they are trying to evade other planes in the area. Really, the real red flag is to see the Captain being locked out of the cockpit and start banging on the door, now that would definitely be unusual. I hope that most of them didn't know what was going to happen.
Guava is offline