Originally Posted by
pa3lsvt
BDO training is not "good stuff" - it's a garbage 'science' boondoggle. BDOs are more likely to identify someone that is a threat to aviation security by wearing a blindfold and guessing - something that has been demonstrated by evaluation of the program by GAO. In fact, BDOs have primarily "detected" crimes that are in no way related to aviation security (smuggling, human trafficking) when they manage to guess correctly. Honestly, defending that program simply proves that you drink the TSA Kool-Aid willingly.
I play poker and a part of the game is behavior detection ("tells") vs. opponents that are actively trying to deceive. Any player worth their salt knows that tells are used ONLY when a very close decision has to be made, as they are well-known to be very unreliable as a primary indicator. Anyone that has read Caro's "Book of Poker Tells" knows more about human behavior and how we exhibit signs of stress than the average person. I can loan you a copy if you want to round out your BDO training.
For example: My adrenaline amps up when I'm bluffing. My adrenaline amps up when I have a big hand and have a good chance of winning a pot. The bigger the pot or bluff, the larger the reaction.
The physical indications are exactly the same in both cases (dilated pupils, throbbing carotid in my neck, slight shaking of hands, stiffness of movement, among others). So when I use my hand to cover my neck and tilt my head down to hide my eyes behind the brim of my baseball cap and am very careful with how I place my bet in front of me - am I bluffing or do I have that flush? At that point, my opponent is only guessing if they rely solely on my body language.
Wow, a personal attack in the first paragraph, awesome days indeed. I will key you in on a little something, the principles of behavior detection studies and interviewing, and card playing and just about any other situation where you are taught to "read people" are the same. Do some research into the behavioral studies by most recognized sources and programs and you will see common themes and conclusions. The same things you mention here, are in every single study of behavioral analysis, recognition and interpretation - soooo, which is it? The stuff in your book and that you use playing cards is either effective, or junk science, so which is it? Be careful how quickly you answer though, because the answer you give indicates that the same statement holds for every other behavioral program (or study or card playing book, or interrogation manual, or interviewing technique manual) that uses these same types of behavioral observations and analysis.