I've read all 20 pages, but am still torn about where to stay on an upcoming trip. This Japan-newbie could use some help from you all.

I have 10 nights total in Japan - 2 nights at Conrad Tokyo, 3 nights at a ryokan in Matsuyama, Shikoku, 2 nights at RC Kyoto, then will be heading back to Tokyo for the final 3 nights.

Based on what I've read here, I'm leaning toward the Shangri-La, MO, or Pen. Any recommendations? Would like the hotel to be close to food/shopping, and a contrast in location and experience from the Conrad.