Moderator: British Airways Executive Club, Iberia Airlines, Airport Lounges and Environmentally Friendly Travel
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: London, UK
Posts: 22,235
My own thoughts:
In favour
- posts marked by the community as helpful could assist others with the task of identifying valuable content for inclusion in wikiposts and other resource threads
- potentially declutters busy threads - reduction of duplicate comments etc. This thread is not a bad case in point
Downsides
- the user feedback plug-in selected by Internet Brands for last month's short trial lacked elegance IMHO. However that's not say this was the only plug-in available. There are plenty of forums with user feedback enabled that avoid over dominant "like" tags
Other thoughts
- I'm not convinced by claims that the user feedback tool will be gamed. As far as I have read there's no benefit to be gained by using the tool insincerely.
- if adopted, my preference is for universal adoption. No forum opt outs. We trust members to post responsibly so the same goes for providing user feedback to posts
- im not convinced that the tool will create or encourage cliquey behaviour although it may highlight existing cliquey behaviour
- personally, I believe this function should be given a proper trial run. It works on other bulletin boards, we have Internet Brands support and experience to guide us through this process
Last edited by Prospero; Jan 13, 2015 at 1:34 pm