Jaybee:
I did the same thing you did. I subscribed to Time Magazine (through AutoMallOnline) on 2/25/02. Still haven't received my points. I've emailed Customer Service at Automallonline 4 times asking when the miles are going to be posted. Still haven't heard a response from them. Meanwhile, I just received my 2nd Time magazine. Since I hadn't heard from Automallonline, I hurried up and cancelled the subscription.
As someone stated on Flyertalk: "Automallonline is on my poo-poo list".
I just love that phrase!!