Originally Posted by
Finkface
Well I was expecting it and was prepared to argue the matter (Mr. Fink was prepared to be mortified and slink out with his tail between his legs). Nowhere on the passes does it say that it must be an award booking using AP miles. It just says that one must be on an award ticket. I don't have the passes anymore but you can read the actual verbiage yourself. Maybe even post it here for others' opinions. But I remember that I felt confident I was on solid ground based on the wording on the passes.
I think you got very lucky.
These are the terms and conditions, stated on the pass:
When visiting a Maple Leaf Lounge, this pass is valid in conjunction with a confirmed same-day departing
Aeroplan ClassicFlight or
Market Fare flight reward ticket for a scheduled flight operated by Air Canada, Air Canada Express or Air Canada Rouge. This pass is not valid with any other airline.
Note to Air Canada Agent: (separate box at bottom)
Please ensure customer is traveling on an Aeroplan Flight Reward, then void and return redeemed guest passes to Maple Leaf Lounge - YUL 1267.